clinicians.build · interactive

The Report Card CMS Just Tore Up

CMS proposed sunsetting traditional MIPS starting in 2029. Before the eulogies, look at the program's own data: half a million clinician score records from the latest public QPP file, in one distribution. It's a quality program where nearly everyone gets an A — and the punishment concentrates on the smallest practices. Step through the four chapters below; the chart morphs to tell each one.

Built on ↓ CMS — "CMS Proposes Transformational Medicare Reforms…" (CY2027 PFS proposed rule, Jul 2026)
Data: CMS Quality Payment Program experience file, PY2024 · via MIMI Labs

What a decade of MIPS actually produced.

87.2
avg final score (of 100), reporters
−9%
max penalty on Medicare payments
+0.4%
avg adjustment, reporters only
27%
small-practice records that didn't report at all

Half a million report cards at once

What this chart can't tell you: ① One bar-unit here is a TIN/NPI record, not a person — a clinician billing under two organizations appears twice, and CMS publishes no clean dedup key. ② This is PY2024 data, released after the performance year; it is not a real-time scorecard. ③ A score of 87 is built from measures clinicians chose to report — the distribution measures documentation capacity at least as much as care quality. The +0.4% adjustment is reporters only; including non-reporters brings the record-level average to +0.24%. That's the actual indictment: a signal this saturated can't tell a good clinician from a good billing department, which is why CMS is replacing it.
The builder read: every registry, dashboard, and eCQM vendor built for this curve now has a 2029 countdown clock. The replacement — MVPs, ACO reporting, outcome-tied software payment — is being specced in public, in a comment period, right now. Nobody sane starts new construction on traditional MIPS today.
Read the CMS proposed rule announcement → Or read today's newsletter →
clinicians.build · an interactive companion to the Builder's Briefing
Sources: CMS press release (CY2027 PFS proposed rule) · CMS Quality Payment Program PY2024 experience file via MIMI Labs
MimiLabs table mimi_ws_1.datacmsgov.qpp · PY2024 · extract mimi_src_file_date=2024-12-31 · queries 6a5b25dda981be4cadba1583 (score bins) / 6a5b25f2a981be4cadba1586 (adjustments) · report ba158a
473,184 reporting records + 30,733 non-reporting records · score bands: 0–18.75 → −9% · <75 → negative · 75 → neutral · >75 → positive
⚠︎ AI-generated · not reviewed by a human · verify against the linked sources before relying on it