Brendan Keeler on Scan.com's $220M: networks are the most durable business in healthcare, and the label does not come for free. So here is the arithmetic that decides whether one is buildable. Integrate the ten biggest billers in Medicare lab and you hold 22.3% of the volume. The ten biggest in imaging get you 1.08%.
Pharmacy got Surescripts. Imaging and labs did not. The usual explanation is regulatory — e-prescribing had a mandate and a DEA hook, planned care never did. That is true and it is not the whole answer.
The other half is a counting problem. A network is only buildable if a small number of endpoints holds a large share of the volume, because that is what lets you launch with coverage worth paying for. So: how many organizations do you actually have to wire up?
Two companies are a fifth of Medicare lab volume. The largest single imaging biller in the country is half of one percent.
The five largest lab billers in Medicare Part B are LabCorp and Quest entities — one NPI alone is 4.4% of all lab services. The five largest imaging billers are companies most clinicians have never heard of: Symphony Diagnostic Services, Mobile Images Acquisition, Berger and Burrow Enterprises. Mobile X-ray vendors, mostly. Number one is 0.51%.
| rank | lab & pathology | share | imaging | share |
|---|
If concentration is what makes a network buildable, some state should be the easy beachhead. Each dot below is one state or territory. Horizontal is how many distinct NPIs bill Medicare imaging there (log scale, 1 to ~15,000). Vertical is what the ten biggest of them hold. A dot high on the left is a market you could corner with ten phone calls.
With no floor, the chart has states where the ten biggest imaging billers hold 100% of the volume. Those are the Army, Air Force and Pacific military post offices and the Northern Mariana Islands — each with ten or fewer billing NPIs. Just below them sit the Virgin Islands at 92% (20 NPIs) and Guam at 82% (37). Drag the floor to 70,000 services and every one of them is gone, Puerto Rico included. What remains is a wall: no state above 37% (Wyoming, 306 NPIs), and the five largest imaging states — California, Florida, Texas, New York, Illinois — all under 5.3%.
The one real outlier is Maryland at 23%, and it is one company: Symphony Diagnostic Services, the mobile x-ray firm that is also the largest single imaging biller in the country. A state-level “market” you could corner turns out to be a vendor with a van.
The builder read: if your imaging product depends on retrieval, there is no beachhead market where ten integrations gets you coverage. Price the fax, the phone call and the CD-ROM into the plan from day one — then ask honestly whether retrieval is the product rather than a cost you absorb.