On Nov. 5, Dr. Ambreén Zaman Riaz wrote that AI scribes didn’t remove documentation work, they moved it: “The interface has shifted from typing to vigilance.” One of the things you’re now checking for is whether the draft supports the bill. So did the bill move? Here are twelve years of Medicare office visits for established patients, … of them in 2024, split by visit level, next to the trend line from before 2020.
Primary source:Ambreén Zaman Riaz, MD, “AI Didn’t Reduce Clinician Burden. It Just Moved It,” MedCity News, Nov. 5, 2026. Data: CMS Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners – by Geography & Service, via MIMI Labs table datacmsgov.mupphy_geo, National rows, CY2013–2024, CPT 99211–99215 (established-patient office/outpatient visits), all places of service. Counts are tot_srvcs; dollars are avg_mdcr_pymt_amt × tot_srvcs. Medicare fee-for-service only.
actual share of established visits2013–2019 trend, extended2021 coding rule change · 2023–24 scribe rollouts
Actual share–
Trend said–
Above trend–
Visits that year–
The trend is a straight-line fit to 2013–2019, before COVID and the 2021 rule. Hover a point for the year’s counts.
The middle of the curve stayed on its line
Level 4 and 5 visits (99214 + 99215) were … of established visits in 2013 and … in 2024. They gained about … points a year before 2020, and the line drawn from those years predicted … for 2024. The 2022–24 climb ran a little faster than the old pace, but only enough to catch back up to the line after a slow COVID stretch. If scribes pushed visits up a level across the board, it doesn’t stand out from the decade-long trend nationally, at least not yet.
The top level did not
Level 5 (99215) is different. It barely moved from 2013 to 2019 (… to …). It jumped in 2021, when CMS let clinicians pick the level by medical decision-making or total time, and it kept climbing to … in 2024, against … on the old trend. That’s … more level-5 visits than the trend predicts, in a single year. Medicare paid … for 99215 in 2024. A draft note that captures every problem discussed and every minute spent tends to support a higher level. That makes the billing line one of the things you are checking for.
Where this is thin — read before quoting
This can’t isolate scribes. Public claims don’t record whether a note was drafted by AI. The 2021 guideline change, higher 2021 payment rates, telehealth, and an older, sicker Medicare population all push in the same direction. The shaded 2023–24 band shows when large systems were rolling scribes out. It is not a measure of how many visits used one.
The total shrank. Established visits fell from … in 2019 to … in 2024, partly as people moved to Medicare Advantage, which isn’t in this file. A share can rise because low-level visits left, not because high-level ones grew.
Level 1 (99211) is mostly nurse visits. It spiked in 2020–21 (COVID testing and vaccines) and then fell. It’s included in the denominator and doesn’t change the picture.
A straight line is a modest model. Use the trend as a reference, not a counterfactual. A specialty-by-specialty view is in the explorer.