Seven and a Half Percent
Becker’s ranked 25 health systems by operating margin through September. Providence took in $7.8 billion in the quarter and kept $4 million. A $300,000 tool is nothing next to the first number. Next to the second it is 7.5%. Here is the same ask against every system on the list, measured both ways.
Read Becker’s margin ranking →
Or read today’s newsletter →
Primary source: Madeline Scheetz, “From 31.1% to -3%: 25 health systems ranked by Q3 operating margins,” Becker’s Hospital Review, November 20, 2026. Revenue and operating income as printed in each row. Ten rows are for the nine months ended Sept. 30, not the quarter; by default they are divided by three to put every system on a per-quarter footing (switch it off below). The $300,000 tool is an illustration, as in the newsletter.
Each row is a system, in Becker’s order. The grey dot is your ask as a share of the system’s revenue. The red dot is the same ask as a share of its operating income, what was left after expenses. The line between them is how far the number moves when you change the denominator. Press replay to watch it move.
ask ÷ revenue ask ÷ operating income × operating loss: nothing left
Providence
Kaiser Permanente
median system
systems where it’s 1%+ or a loss
80/20 lens
Against revenue the ask never reaches a fifth of a percent at any system on the list. Against what was left it runs from about 0.01% at HCA to 7.5% at Providence, and the order has little to do with size. Kaiser has the most revenue on the list and a 1.4% margin, and the ask is still a sliver of its $495 million. Providence is smaller and kept $4 million. The two systems with operating losses have no denominator at all. That is the whole point of the newsletter piece: your request gets sized against the bottom line, so walk in with what it moves on that line, not what it costs.
Read before you quote it
- Not exhaustive. Becker’s says so: 25 systems that had reported, not a sample of the industry.
- Mixed periods. Ten rows (BayCare, WVU, Inova, Texas Health, Banner, Memorial Sloan Kettering, Corewell, BJC, SSM, Altru) are nine-month figures. Dividing by three gives an average quarter, not the actual third quarter.
- Tenet’s row doesn’t add up as printed ($5.6B revenue, $4.6B expenses, $1.8B operating income). This page uses the printed operating income and marks the row with an asterisk.
- Revenue is rounded to a tenth of a billion in the source, so the grey dots are approximate. Operating income is printed more precisely, so the red dots are the reliable ones.
- Operating income is defined by each system. Becker’s doesn’t say how; a Becker’s sidebar calls Bon Secours Mercy’s figure “recurring operating income,” so some rows may be adjusted figures. One quarter is not a trend.
- A system is not your hospital. For a single hospital’s numbers, see the companion explorer of 2,505 Medicare cost reports.