AMA delegates voted to make EHRs flag the quiet downcode: a level 4 visit paid as a level 3, with no denial to notice. A resolution at the meeting put the loss at $28,000 to $74,000 per family physician a year. Here is what Medicare’s own volume can account for.
Primary source: Tanya Albert Henry, “AMA takes on downcoding and will ask EHR vendors to help track it,” AMA, Nov. 9, 2026. Data: CMS Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners by Provider & Service, CY2024 (via MIMI Labs). 61,889 family physicians with at least one reported level 4 or 5 office-visit row.
One step down is worth $34.34 on a 99214 and $50.57 on a 99215 at 2024 national Medicare office rates. Each line below is 1% of family physicians in Medicare. It climbs as a payer pays more of their level 4 and 5 visits one level lower. The pink band is the AMA range.
Share of level 4/5 visits paid one level lower: 100%
What-if: Medicare FFS is 1 in 1 of these visits
1% of family physicianshas reached $28k at this ratemedianAMA estimate, $28k–$74k
Median FP loses
FPs at or past $28k
Highest line (top 1% of FPs)
All 61,889 FPs
The lines are straight because the exposure is linear: double the downcode rate, double the dollars. The slope of each line is that clinician’s 2024 Medicare level 4/5 volume times the one-step price gap. Hover a line for its value at 100%.
80/20 · the gap is the story
Even if a payer downcoded every level 4 and 5 visit, the median family physician’s Medicare volume would only produce about , and in 100 would reach $28,000. If the AMA’s range is right, most of the money sits in commercial and Medicare Advantage claims that no public dataset shows by clinician. That’s why the ask is an EHR alert built from your own remittance files: nobody outside your billing office can see it.
Read this before quoting a number
Exposure, not loss. No public file records downcodes. Each line prices a hypothetical share of visits paid one level lower.
Traditional Medicare is the yardstick, not the payer accused. The AMA directive names “public and private payers, including Medicare Advantage.” Fee-for-service Medicare is used only because its claims are public per clinician.
National prices, one step. Gaps use 2024 national average allowed amounts by code and setting (office: 99214→99213 $34.34, 99215→99214 $50.57, 99204→99203 $55.30, 99205→99204 $54.41). Only one-level downcodes are counted.
Undercount. CMS suppresses clinician-code rows under 11 patients. “Family physician” is CMS’s Family Practice specialty code, individuals only. The lines are percentile midpoints, approximate: counting clinicians directly instead of lines, 3,388 of 61,889 family physicians (5.5%) would reach $28k at 100%, and 155 (0.3%) would reach $74k.
The panel slider is your assumption, priced at Medicare rates, so it still understates commercial dollars.
$28k–$74k is a resolution’s estimate, not a study, and the AMA story doesn’t say which payers it covers. Treat it as a claim to check against your own remittances.