The Downcode Exposure Explorer
A payer pays your level 4 visit as a level 3, and the claim still says “paid.” Here is every Medicare clinician in 17 big specialties, 100 dots each, priced at what that one step down would cost them in a year. Slide the downcode rate and see who ever gets near the AMA’s number.
Read the AMA story on the downcoding vote →
Or read today’s newsletter →
Primary source: Tanya Albert Henry, “AMA takes on downcoding and will ask EHR vendors to help track it,” AMA, Nov. 9, 2026. Data: CMS Medicare Physician & Other Practitioners by Provider & Service, CY2024 (via MIMI Labs). CPT 99204, 99205, 99214, 99215, individual clinicians, office and facility settings.
The AMA story carries a resolution’s estimate that silent downcoding costs $28,000 to $74,000 per family physician per year. Medicare’s public claims file doesn’t record downcodes. It does record how many level 4 and 5 visits each clinician billed, and what one level lower pays. That gives you the ceiling: the most a payer could take on that volume.
1% of the specialty’s cliniciansinside or past the AMA rangeAMA family-physician estimate, $28k–$74k
FP median
FP at or past $28k
Rate for FP median to hit $28k
All clinicians, total
Each row is one specialty. Each dot is 1% of that specialty’s clinicians (the midpoint of a percentile bin), so every row holds 100 dots whatever its size. The scale is logarithmic so the low end stays readable: each gridline step is a multiple, and dots under $250 or over $150k pile at the edges. The black tick is the median. Hover a dot for its value. Click any dot to make its row the readout specialty.
80/20 · what the dots say
At Medicare prices and Medicare volume, a payer that paid every level 4 and 5 visit one level lower would take about from the median family physician in a year. The AMA’s low end is that. So the money the resolution describes has to live somewhere this file can’t see: commercial and Medicare Advantage claims, at commercial rates. That’s the same blind spot the AMA wants EHR vendors to fix: the public data shows what was billed, not what came back.
Read this before quoting a number
- This is exposure, not loss. No public file records downcodes. The chart prices a hypothetical: if this share of a clinician’s level 4 and 5 visits had been paid one level lower.
- Traditional Medicare is the price list, not the culprit. The AMA’s directive names “public and private payers, including Medicare Advantage.” Fee-for-service Medicare is used here because it is the only payer whose claims are public by clinician.
- One step, national prices. The step is the 2024 national average Medicare allowed amount for the billed code minus the code below it, by setting. In the office that is $34.34 for 99214→99213, $50.57 for 99215→99214, $55.30 for 99204→99203 and $54.41 for 99205→99204. Local fee schedules move these by roughly a fifth either way.
- Missing rows. CMS drops any clinician-code row with fewer than 11 patients, and level 4/5 visits are only part of a clinic’s day. Clinicians with no qualifying row aren’t counted.
- The panel slider is an assumption. It scales Medicare volume up at Medicare prices. Commercial plans usually pay more per visit, so even this understates a full panel. Set it to what you know about your own payer mix.
- The $28k–$74k figure comes from a resolution, not a study, as the newsletter notes. The AMA story gives $40k–$180k for multispecialty practices. Neither says which payers.